RSPB Scotland Head of Investigations, Ian Thomson, brings us this latest blog following the publication of a Scottish Government commissioned review of satellite tagged golden eagles.
This afternoon, on the floor of the Scottish Parliament, the Cabinet Secretary for the Environment, Climate Change and Land Reform made a series of announcements aimed at bearing down on those who continue to kill Scotland’s birds of prey. This followed the publication of the Scottish Government-commissioned review of satellite-tagged eagles instigated after the suspicious disappearance of eight birds in the Monadhliath mountains south-east of Inverness, between 2011 and 2016.
The report showed that approximately one third of tagged golden eagles fledging from Scottish nests are being illegally killed, with a clear link between these crimes and land intensively managed for driven grouse shooting - particularly in four areas of the eastern and central Highlands.
None of the report’s findings came as a big surprise to those of us who have recovered the bodies of poisoned eagles from the Angus Glens or upper Donside, or searched in vain for birds that have suddenly and inexplicably disappeared in the mountains above the River Findhorn.
But the report is utterly damning nonetheless. The main findings are:
In other words, almost a third of young tagged golden eagles dispersing from their natal areas, where presumably they are tolerated or even welcomed, are being killed particularly when they move into four identified areas where intensive grouse moor management is the main land-use, and this is constraining the national population of golden eagles.
The report also makes clear that wind farms were not associated with any recorded golden eagle deaths, and it also completely exonerates tagging itself with “no discernible adverse effects on the welfare, behaviour or survival of the birds”.
This report demonstrates an astonishing scale of systematic, organised criminality. And yet, it is likely that none of this would have come to light had these birds not been fitted with satellite tags.
When you consider these findings alongside the similar disappearances of satellite-tagged white tailed eagles, red kites, goshawks, peregrines and hen harriers, not included this review, and remember that satellite-tagged birds form a very small proportion of the populations of these species, the overall numbers of eagles and other protected raptors that are actually being killed must be staggering.
Recognising this, the Cabinet Secretary has announced the setting up of an independent enquiry to look at the environmental impact of grouse moor management and to recommend options for regulation, including licensing. She also said that government officials are looking into immediate measures that will bear down on areas with a long and proven history of the criminal targeting of protected birds of prey, as highlighted by the review. We look forward to hearing more detail on what is proposed.
This report completely and finally bankrupts the myth that raptor persecution is in long term decline and we hope that its publication and today’s announcements represent a watershed moment for the future conservation of our birds of prey.
So will representatives of the shooting industry finally stand up and publicly acknowledge the level of crime that is taking place? Will forward-thinking members of the shooting community – gamekeepers, sporting tenants, factors and landowners - reject the denials, excuses and obfuscation we have heard so often and join with us in a progressive partnership to develop a robust licensing scheme for gamebird hunting in Scotland, with a regulatory system that helps tackle wildlife crime and delivers a range of public benefits?
We’ll find out in the coming days and weeks...
Jackie Brown is RSPB Scotland’s Volunteering Development Officer. Here she details why she loves working with our RSPB Scotland volunteers and how we’ll be celebrating all they do for us during this year’s Volunteers’ Week, 1st-7th June.
Celebrating our volunteers
Volunteers give the most generous of gifts: their time. They are as unique as the organisations they chose to donate time to but all united by their shared desire to do something meaningful for a cause that matters to them.
It’s incredibly rewarding to work in this field, with the passionate and enthusiastic people who give volunteering a go. Having a special week dedicated to celebrate the time and talent they share with us is a great way to show our appreciation and highlight all they do for us across Scotland. Volunteers’ Week this year will be recognising volunteering as the golden thread running through the country’s communities and wider society.
Volunteers are vital to the strength and vitality of Scottish society, with their contribution valued at £2 billion every year. According to recent research, Scotland’s young people are particularly engaged with participation levels at 52%; nearly double the adult figure of 27%.
With so many people volunteering, there is a huge range of achievements to shout about and RSPB Scotland has a lot to thank our volunteers for.
From busy offices to braving the elements on remote islands, our volunteers are taking action for nature that is really making a difference. Without this vast pool of time and talent so much less would get done, fewer people would hear our message and all important connections to the environment and wildlife would be missed.
As detailed in last year State of Nature report Scotland’s wildlife is in crisis so the time and effort put in by our 2,200 volunteers is invaluable, whether it be as a one off, a few hours per year or every week without fail.
To all of our volunteers RSPB Scotland says: your passion is infectious, your support invaluable and your contribution hugely appreciated, THANK YOU.
During volunteers week we’ll be celebrating all that our volunteers do and the impact their donated time makes.
First off, I’d like to highlight some of the great work of our volunteers at our Edinburgh headquarters. Many people, when they think of RSPB Scotland, may assume our volunteering is all outdoor based but as you’ll hear our office volunteers do an incredible amount for us; from getting the important headlines from our papers to helping kids make a connection to nature, over 100 volunteers give their time to help in our offices.
Brian, Leader of the RSPB Edinburgh Local Group
One of these fantastic volunteers, Brian is being celebrated by the Volunteer Centre in Edinburgh at their Inspiring Volunteering Awards ceremony and we couldn’t be more pleased for this well earned recognition. Not only is Brian the leader of the RSPB Edinburgh Local group, he also helps out at our events, helping our Community Greenspaces Project Officer and even fundraising by looking after pin badge boxes around the city. His passion for birds and other wildlife comes across when he is chatting to people attending events and he is happy to share his knowledge to anyone interested in the natural world.
Nigel delving into the day's news
Another of our amazing volunteers Nigel has been volunteering with our media team for over 12 years. He comes in every week to collate our media coverage - a really important service for finding out where our message to inspire people to help save nature is reaching.
Along with Brian and Nigel we have volunteers helping in most of our departments in Edinburgh taking on roles in everything from policy research to welcoming guests at our reception and they all give their absolute best.
We’re marking Volunteers’ Week here at RSPB Scotland through our blog and social media so keep an eye on Scottish Nature Notes, and our Facebook and Twitter, to discover more.
And if you’ve been inspired to give some of your time to us take a look at our volunteering page to discover more about the opportunities we have!
Wildlife friendly farming is an integral part of RSPB Scotland’s work. In this blog Jack Fleming, our area manager in the Argyll Islands, and David Maynard, our community information and tourism officer at Loch Gruinart, take us through how RSPB Scotland is farming for wildlife on Islay.
Farming for wildlife on Islay
Loch Gruinart - Dave Maynard
Farming for wildlife. That, in a nutshell, is what RSPB Scotland Loch Gruinart, our 1700ha reserve on Islay, is all about. And if it wasn’t for Aoradh, the RSPB Scotland owned farm, we wouldn’t have a reserve at Loch Gruinart at all. The farm was purchased in 1984 for the conservation of barnacle and white-fronted geese which arrive from Greenland every year in October.
Along with being an important habitat for these geese it’s now also managed for a range of wildlife from corncrakes, cuckoos, and breeding waders such as lapwing, redshanks, snipe, curlews, greenshanks and godwits who visit in the summer, to the resident population of chough and, not forgetting the hen harriers. It’s not just birds though! Rare marsh fritillary butterfly, bats, reptiles and plants also benefit.
On Aoradh, year-round seasonal farming requirements and diverse wildlife habitat management methods synchronise to create a fascinating combination of successful agricultural and conservation practices. Farming and wildlife conservation really do go ‘hand-in-hand’ here.
In order to suitably manage the farm for conservation, Aoradh has a spring calving suckler herd of 200 cross-bred Limousin/Aberdeen Angus/ Shorthorn cows and a flock of 200 North Country Cheviot sheep (primarily to control ragwort and dockens) on the grazing areas. The sale of the calves and lambs generates our income. It’s really important that Aoradh is run as a successful working farm especially for RSPB Scotland’s advocacy work. We must use the same techniques and equipment and face the same challenges as other farms in the area; our farm must function at the highest levels of livestock quality and welfare, matching other farmers on Islay which is renowned for the quality of livestock produced on the island; and we have to use standard techniques means that we can accurately assess the cost of delivering conservation. This allows RSPB Scotland to advise land managers and Government of the funding required to support this vital work. Ultimately the farm needs to make money so it costs as little as possible to deliver what is an immense amount of biodiversity.
Meat is the farm’s produce and revenue earner and is a by-product of our conservation methods. The benefit to RSPB Scotland is that although we are managing for red list wildlife species, we regularly top the local and occasionally national sales and shows, giving us more ways to engage with people about our work and enhancing our credibility as commercial land managers. This would not be achievable by stereotypical conservation methods and has also led to the adoption of what is basically a lowland herd in a highland setting.
Our livestock are our frontline conservationists, assisting us in determining land management requirements for many of the red list species we practice conservation for. They perform important tasks that today’s mechanisation cannot always successfully complete.
Chough benefit from sheep and cattle at our Loch Gruinart reserve
By close cropping, our sheep and cattle ensure a short grass sward, so that the resident population of rare chough can probe into the topsoil for food. The cattle constantly provide ubiquitous ‘cow pats’, micro-habitats for over-wintering dung beetle larvae and ‘leatherjackets’, the larval form of the crane fly, which form the chough’s diet of choice. Manure produced by our cattle is also used for the creation of corncrake corridors – strips of land set aside for the cultivation of ‘early cover’, good examples of which include flag irises and stinging nettles, hand sown in a substrate of ‘muck’.
Later on in the year, after the waders’ breeding season has come to an end, cattle are put into the wetland areas for targeted grazing and rush topping operations. Cows, after weaning, are also put onto available moorland to keep grazing in order which also promotes the growth and availability of devil’s-bit scabious, the plant upon which the caterpillars of the marsh fritillary butterfly feed.
I’m really proud of the work we do here at Loch Gruinart and Aoradh. It’s a great thing to be able to see year round the positive impact that our successful farming methods have on the wildlife and habitats here, and the role our farm has on influencing farming conservation policies across the country.
The Oa - Jack Fleming
At The Oa we own and farm 2,000 hectares of this rugged landscape. The high conservation value of The Oa Reserve, with its range of coastal and heathland habitats and its population of chough, has been recognised by designation as SSSI and SPA. These habitats and the biodiversity they support are characteristic of much of Islay and the Inner Hebrides and depend on active management utilising a low intensity, extensive farming system.
With 140 breeding cows and 600 ewes this is not a small operation. The cows are a mix of pure Highland, Simmental/Highland or Luing and Limousin cross. Each group of cattle is placed on selected areas to make best use of the breed characteristics and deliver the habitat management we need. The pure Highland cows, with their foraging abilities, thrive on the open hill ground; the Simmental crosses do well on the slightly less exposed glens and the Limousin cattle benefit from the better fields. The sheep are predominantly Scottish Blackface, renowned for their hardiness. By using the livestock in this way we maximise both the conservation benefit and the financial return for the Society.
The calves from the cows and lambs from the ewes, in common with almost all stock on Islay, are sold as “stores” that is; they are sold on to other farmers on the mainland to complete their growing. Islay is rightly regarded as an island that produces the highest quality of livestock and buyers come from all over the UK. Like our colleagues farming at Loch Gruinart, we fully play our part in this, taking local and national prizes for our cattle in particular. Through our dealing with specialists, our pure Highland bullocks may often grace the dining tables as far from Islay as south east England!
All this agricultural activity absolutely underpins the conservation interests on The Oa. As Dave has mentioned, of particular importance is the connection between cattle grazing and chough, with the cattle providing the correct sward heights for the chough to forage amongst and the dung pats that are the source of the dung beetles and larvae that form such a crucial part of the chough diet. Areas of land are managed for breeding waders and wintering geese and our pockets of arable management have seen flocks of 1,200 wintering twites – probably the largest such flock in the UK! Work is in hand to increase the area we manage for corncrake and we are hopeful that we can increase their population in this part of the island. Without the farming we could not hope to deliver the diversity which makes The Oa such a special place for wildlife and humans alike.
Find out more about our food and farming work across the UK here.
Open Farm Sunday is coming up on 11th June. Why not visit your local farms taking part and discover the farmland wildlife that lives near you? More information can be found on the Open Farm Sunday website.